yes, sorry, it was bad.
in the immediate aftermath of having watched feroze kamardeen’s ‘venice’ last night, my mind didn’t somehow register what i felt about it. over the course of dinner and spirited discussion following my viewing of ‘venice’ though, my opinion more or less formed itself. this morning i woke up and i knew exactly what i thought. the more i think about it, all the lurid detail, the less reason i have to believe there was anything not-bad about it.
this is only my opinion, and it shouldn’t count for all that much, but i really haven’t met anyone who thinks differently or is of a different opinion. everyone i’ve spoken to that’s seen ‘venice’ in it’s almost 17 day run at the lionel wendt theatre has not had anything to say about it but how bad it was ; and these people vary in age, theatrical experience and knowledge and taste. no one was impressed. no one was even entertained. perhaps this is something for the director and producers to think about.
now, i really can’t even begin to breakdown all the things i felt they did wrong. but my main concern has been this : is the director and the producers aware of the quality of what they produced? do they, as educated, experienced actors, directors and producers, realize how superficial and meaningless their production was and simply just put it on anyway, because they know they had their ticket sales, or are they genuinely unaware of the humiliation they are causing themselves? are they at all of the opinion that it was any good, because if that wasn’t the case, then it could only mean one thing : that it’s about the money and the money alone.
the singing was terrible, or maybe it was more the choice of song and that the balance between the musicians and the singers was completely off, making the band a lot louder than the singers and thus making the singers sound drowned and weak. portia’s maids were impossible ; i recognized a few faces, they are fairly established and well known as ’singers’, but they didn’t have any of the presence or the command of their voices that justified this, and most of the time, there was so much pure action amongst them, they were constantly upstaging all the speaking characters and all the most important conversation.
the jessica and lorenzo of this cast were the truly strong voices. they were technically great singers, but they sang all of ‘hanging by a moment’ in the same position, holding each other, looking into each other’s eyes the entire time, not moving, completely immobile, letting the vast, empty stage that was all their own go to total waste. this is only one aspect in a line of things that made me think this : that the entire cast for some odd reason, thought they were in a movie. that’s about the only way i can describe it. this was one phase of the play, the other being that ‘high-school’ play phase. so i felt like i was either watching a really bad movie, or i felt like i was watching a really bad high school play.
first for the movie phase : everyone had clip-on mikes, which added to this movie-effect. without the need to project to the audience, the actors seemed to forget that the audience was there at all. they were speaking very intimately to each other, their facial expressions (if at all) little and subtle, as if they were waiting for the camera to zoom in on them. shylock seemed to even think that he could deliver all his best speeches facing his back to the audience completely. the bad mood music, the stagnant postures while singing, the invisible facial expression and the lack of connectivity with the audience : i felt left out. the production didn’t involve me, it didn’t make me feel anything.
the high-school play phase : oh good lord. most of the direction, the movement, particularly in the crowd scenes, was SO unbelievably boring and predictable. it was just like making a child direct a crowd scene and watching the outcome : the extras were constantly upstaging the main charcters with large hang gestures and general goofing off ; falling over each other, bumping into each other, causing unnecessary commotion and making people laugh at all the wrong people, for all the wrong reasons, in all the wrong places. none of the direction was even remotely interesting, it incorporated nothing novel, nothing new. with all the technology and all the years of education and experience, the coolest they could do was moving platforms. people still had their hands folded when they ‘delivered’ their lines, one charatcer took his/her exit before there was a somewhat curious pause in which space there was an empty stage followed by the other character making his/her entrance. it was banal and cliche.
portia and nerissa were seemingly the only good things about this production at all, they delivered their characters consistently and played them well. shylock had his moments, but it’s hard to tell because the production kept screwing things up for him. the moment he’d make me want to sit up and listen, he’d have to sing a song or something, thereby ruining any little spell he had managed to cast even momentarily.
the costumes were great, but so what? the backdrops (a different one for almost each scene) were cool, but the stationary set onstage was pretty ugly and impractical.
it’s impossible and criminal for the director and producers of ‘venice’ to think that they did a good job. they spent a lot of money, they marketed it wisely and worked with almost the best in every field. they have no excuse. like i was telling someone, the only way in which i can describe this is by saying that it’s like having all the best ingredients and making a really shitty meal. when you have good ingredients, there is no excuse for one that makes a really shitty meal. when you have all the resources, there is no excuse for one that produces a really shitty play.
it seems to me like it’s nothing but just simple lethargy. they put up a godawful production : do they notice? how can such an experienced, learned man as the director of ‘venice’ think honestly to himself that it was good? and if they know, then do they just not care? they just can’t be bothered?
if they were going for pure mass appeal, then they got it. they had a full house almost every night. they earned more than their fair share. for what? i feel cheated. the merchant of venice is such a fantastic play, i almost feel personally offended.
this is all i can say…i talked so much about it that my feelings of frustration are exhausted.
who’s going to tell him? who’s going to stop him from doing another?